Rethinking How We Assess GME Students

MBA Roundtable Winners Amanda Convery, Mandi Bullough and Mark Serva

The MBA Roundtable, an association of graduate business schools, selected a project led by University of Delaware Professors Mark Serva, Amanda Convery and Amanda Bullough at the Alfred Lerner College of Business and Economics as one of two 2021 Innovator Award winners. The other project selected was from the Carey Business School at John Hopkins University.

Serva, Convery and Bullough, with support from Senior Associate Dean of Academic Programs Jack Baroudi, redesigned how the Lerner College assesses graduate management students (GME) by creating an innovative motivational tiered assessment (MTA). Under MTA, students can achieve higher grades only when they exhibit higher levels of intrinsic motivation, because students choose the amount (and difficulty) of work they complete. This new assessment model is changing assumptions about grading in the Lerner MBA program, MTA’s relative advantages, data that support these advantages and how MTA will be integrated into Lerner GME programs in the future.

“The challenge that we address is improving the meaning of graduate management education (GME) grades, and—by extension—differentiating different levels of GME student performance,” said Mark Serva, associate professor of management information systems (MIS) at UD. “My colleagues and I started by questioning the assumptions surrounding grading. After some background research and significant development work and refinement, the result was motivational tiered assessment (MTA), an approach that changes not only how we grade, but also tightly ties grades to the student’s level of intrinsic motivation to learn.”

The MBA Roundtable Innovator Award was created in 2011 to promote educational initiatives that advance innovation in graduate management education and acknowledge the institutions that drive change in the field. The Innovator Award raises awareness of ongoing curricular and co-curricular improvements and educates employers, business school leaders, and faculty about innovative practices of best-in-class MBA and Specialized Masters programs.

Recent News

Wendy Smith receives Academy of Management Annals Decade Award

University of Delaware management professor Wendy Smith has spent much of her career examining a challenge familiar to leaders across industries: how to navigate competing demands without choosing one at the expense of another. Now, research that helped advance the...

Lerner Student Samantha Matisoff’s Olympic-Sized Internship

University of Delaware marketing major Samantha Matisoff loved sports — especially soccer and the U.S. Women’s National Team — but her career trajectory remained uncertain. Following her sophomore year, Matisoff added sport management as a second major and never...

UD SYLP Camp Builds Leadership Through Economics

This article was written by Kim Asarta. Before arriving at the University of Delaware for the Siegfried Youth Leadership Program (SYLP) Economics Camp, Joseph Bratteson hoped to better understand economics, leadership and himself. Bratteson was one of many students...

Dan Alia Named 2026 Study Abroad Faculty Director of the Year

Lerner College Visiting Instructor Dan Alia recently earned the Study Abroad Faculty Director of the Year for Winter 2026 from the University of Delaware’s Center for Global Programs & Services. Last summer Alia received a call from Suresh Sundaram, a marketing...

Two Lerner College Grad Students Named Fulbright Scholars

story written using portions of this UDaily article Lerner College graduate students Charles Walker and Joseph Mezzatesta are two of nine University of Delaware students who are recent recipients of the 2026-27 U.S. Fulbright Scholarship. Walker, a graduate student...